We all know that
Bob Barr is the Presidential nominee and
Wayne Allyn Root is the Vice Presidential nominee, but what happened behind the scenes and away from C-SPAN's cameras?
Previous gossip:
Wednesday/Thursday,
Friday,
Saturday,
Saturday night debateShawn Levasseur
reports wi-fi problems at the convention, and Jason Pye
confirms that it went down in the middle of the debate last night (which explains all the unfinished live-blogs). Robert Stacy McCain
reports that the Barr campaign has their own much better internet connection and has been making it available to journalists. So it's possible that this round of gossip will be skewed in a Barr-friendly direction due to the disparity in internet access.
Anything below that doesn't cite a source is my own observations from watching on C-SPAN.
Pictures: Reason Hit and Run has pictures
here. Liberty Papers has pictures
here.
Platform:Here is the
unofficial draft of the 2008 PlatformDonny Ferguson has the
inside scoop on the process. It sounds like the
anticipated nasty faction fight over the platform didn't happen, which is good.
Delegates' Reactions to the Debate: Jason Pye
claims, "The general consensus seems to be that Barr and Kubby won the debate last night. Everyone I've talked to seems to believe that Ruwart really hurt herself by playing the gender card" and that it "was one of the most anti-intellectual things she could have done." Robert Stacy McCain
confirms he's heard this about Ruwart as well.
Last-Minute Campaigning:Robert Stacy McCain has
video of Barr from Saturday night's reception and TV interviews.
David Weigel
reports, "At the convention tables, the smears have stopped, and the endorsements
have arrived. Three Libertarians have distributed letters in support of
Bob Barr, and the Ruwart campaign has put out a letter with
endorsements from four former LP presidential candidates and two former
VP nominees. Well, sort of. Dave Bergland, Andre Marrou, and Tonie
Nathan explicitly endorse Ruwart, while Michael Badnarik says she's
"pretty, smart, and swings a huge philosophical bat," and Ron Paul
appears in the form of his blurb for
Healing Our World."
Jason Pye
reports that Mike Gravel was circulating a flyer effectively claiming that a vote for Barr is a vote for Obama or Clinton, whereas a vote for Gravel is a vote for McCain. Also, "Another hit piece on Barr is being pushed around this morning about the
donations to Republicans through his PAC, the Bob Barr Leadership Fund" and "I heard this morning that most of the anti-Barr buttons were made by the Phillies campaign." Also, he says a pro-Barr article from a Libertarian site about Bob Barr's record was circulated (
part I,
part II) as was a Washington Times
article about the convention that described Mary Ruwart as the author of a book "defending child pornography." He thinks these articles influenced the delegates' votes.
Delegate Count:There were 652 credentialed delegates at the beginning of the Presidential Nomination vote, with the caveat that additional delegates could be qualified as the day wore on. The rumored busloads of last-minute Barr supporters never arrived and only 626 people voted on the last round so I think Barr's win is legit.
Presidential Nomination Vote:Nomination speeches, interesting tidbits:
Bob Barr's nomination was seconded by Rob Kampia of the Marijuana Policy Project. I think it was a really smart move to have a former opponent endorse him like that. In his speech, Barr finally apologized for his anti-libertarian "mistakes" while in Congress.
George Phillies was nominated by the Outright Libertarians. They only left him a minute to talk.
Mike Jingozian surprised everyone by nominating Mike Gravel. Presidential candidates don't normally nominate their opponents!
Bob Barr's supporters did a campaign signs march in front of the room at the end of the nomination speeches and were booed.
First Ballot:
Interestingly, in the state-by-state results, no one from Alaska voted for Gravel and no one from Nevada voted for Root, but everyone from Massachusetts voted for Phillies.
Christine Smith and Mike Jingozian were eliminated on the first ballot for having less than 5% of the vote.
Christine Smith gave a very angry concession speech attacking Bob Barr and did not endorse another candidate. I can't find a YouTube of her speech, but here's
video of people booing her. She then was interviewed by C-SPAN for several minutes in which she continued to angrily rant about Barr and the supposed takeover of the party by right-wingers. In my opinion it was extremely declasse.
ElfNinosMom has a
good summary of Smith's rant on C-SPAN: "Smith concession speech. Disappointed, but is visibly angry about Barr being on top. Bashes
conservatives. She’s pissed. Says Barr is not a Libertarian, “we don’t
trust you!” She thanks her supporters. Said “put a libertarian on the
ballot”, got boo’d. Damn, that is one angry woman. I get the distinct
impression that she is extremely pissed at getting only 6 votes. Did
she really expect to get more than that?
"Being interviewed, Christine Smith says libertarians are selling
out. Says people are leaving LP if Barr is chosen. Damn, she’s angry
again. Says Barr needs to use the media he brags about to apologize to
people who are in prison because of his laws. Says libertarians are
selling out by supporting Barr. Says it’s all for nothing if we sell
out. Barr is not a libertarian, is wolf in sheep’s clothing, etc."
Barr's reaction, as
overheard by David Weigel: "I guess I'm not getting her vote."
Mike Jingozian endorsed Mike Gravel.
Robert Stacy McCain reports, "One delegate told me that Ruwart seemed visibly angered by Michael Jingozian's endorsement of Mike Gravel. Jingozian had to solicit tokens from other candidates in order to qualify for the C-SPAN debate, and if Ruwart gave Jingozian tokens, she has a right to feel betrayed." David Weigel confirms, "There's a lot of grumbling from Ruwart backers about Jingozian's move."
Second Ballot:
Steve Kubby was eliminated and endorsed Mary Ruwart.
Someone moved to have George Phillies eliminated from the next round to save time because he only got 6%, but the motion was booed down without a second.
ElfNinosMom has a
good summary of what C-SPAN got of Mary Ruwart talking with delegates during the third round of voting: "Mary Ruwart is talking to a small group of people, she seems to have
serious concerns about Bob Barr. She says he will legalize medical
marijuana, but not heroin or crack. She says our media is the internet.
She also says Ron Paul supporters will not support Barr. Libertarians
in the LGBT community are telling her that if Barr is elected, they’re
leaving. She thinks Ron Paul might talk about her, but I think that’s
doubtful."
Third Ballot:
George Phillies was eliminated. His concession speech was his best yet! He said something nice about each of the candidates (although his reference to Barr's and Ruwart's late entry into the race could be seen as a back-handed compliment) and passionately called for unity: "The enemy is NOT IN HERE! The enemy is OUT THERE! The enemy is not our fellow Libertarians!" He did not endorse another candidate.
Fourth Ballot:
Mike Gravel was eliminated and refused to give a concession speech. The C-SPAN camera did get a bit of him talking to his supporters. At one point he said he planned to remain in the Libertarian Party for the rest of his life. However, he kept talking about Libertarians, their positions, and campaigns as "you" and "your" instead of "we" and "our".
ElfNinosMom has a
good summary of what Mike Gravel said on camera to his supporters: "Gravel says this is the end of his political career. He would not
have done anything differently. He is not going to make a speech. He is
going to push the National Initiative until the day he dies. He says
this is all politics as usual, that representative government is
broken, and libertarians have chosen not to fix it.
"He says he would vote for Barr before he’d vote for Ruwart, if it comes down to the two of them."
Jason Pye
reports that Barr and Root met after the fourth ballot to discuss a deal: "Root wanted a guarantee that Barr would not seek the nomination in 2012. Once talk of the
Washington Times article started making its way around the convention, talk of deal started."
Fifth Ballot:
Root is eliminated, endorses Barr, and asks for the Vice Presidential nomination. Everyone knows at this point that it's over for Ruwart. David Weigel
describes the mood, "Ruwart supporters look like they've had their heads shoved underwater:
Barr and Root are doing smiley interviews with the national press."
Sixth Ballot:
Bob Barr wins.
Vice Presidential Nomination Vote:C-SPAN cut away early in the Vice Presidential nomination process. I was able to get ahold of Stephen Gordon and he got the Bob Barr campaign webcam fired up for us, but I initially had problems with the sound. So, I didn't get to watch any of this and thus everything below is gathered second-hand from bloggers or chat rooms (I was in the Independent Political Watch chat room and the Bob Barr chat room).
I heard in one of the chat rooms that many people wanted Mary Ruwart to run for the Vice Presidential nomination but she refused to be on a ticket with Barr. Steve Perkins
confirms, "I learned that multiple offers had been made by the Barr camp to bring
Ruwart on board… before the nominations, and during the rounds. Ruwart
wouldn’t budge, even after it became clear the way things were shaping
up."
Jason Pye
reports, "One of my fellow delegates just switched from Kubby to Root because
Ruwart was offered the VP slot, which she would have easily won. In
other words, this wouldn't even be an issue if Ruwart would have
accepted a deal to support Barr."
Less Antman
explains, "Ruwart explained why she wouldn’t be the VP nominee under Barr. She
said she would have the choice of misrepresenting what she believed
(and what she believes is the correct Libertarian position) and
undercutting Barr on many issues. For example, asked about one of the
central campaign themes of Barr, the Fair Tax, she would feel the need
to say she thought it was a terrible idea and that she agreed with Ron
Paul that the income tax should be abolished and replaced with nothing.
"It was in the interests of not having an LP Presidential and
Vice-Presidential nominee openly disagreeing on major campaign themes,
and not petulance, that she felt she could not run on a ticket with
Barr. I was present while she was discussing the proposal with one of
the Barr people."
The LP vote totals page
indicates that Burns and Lightfoot were eliminated on the first round and Williams withdrew. Jason Pye
reports that all three endorsed Kubby.
I heard in one of the chat rooms that about 25 likely Kubby supporters walked out between the Presidential and Vice Presidential votes. Steve Perkins
confirms, "More importantly, Kubby lost on VP because 20 or more delegates left
the floor following the Barr win. Had they simply stuck around one
more hour, Kubby would have WON."
Root beat Kubby in the second round by 30 votes, and the total votes cast on that ballot were 544 plus however many voted for None of the Above (the LP
vote totals page doesn't report NOTA's votes). 626 votes were cast in the final round of the Presidential nomination race so up to 82 delegates either walked out or otherwise skipped voting in the Vice Presidential race. If most of them were from the radical faction, they would have had more than enough votes to tip the Vice Presidential nomination to Kubby if they had only stayed and fought for it.
Aftermath, Sunday night:Steve Perkins
reports that Christine Smith tried to disrupt the post-nomination press conference. (WTF is her problem?)
David Weigel
reports, "Kubby wanted to speak to angry radicals, and some of them were
beseeching him to lead a walkout, or to return to the convention hall
and denounce the new ticket. Tom Knapp, the work horse of Kubby's
convention effort, told him to speak for unity. So he did, and asked
for a show of hands of how many radicals would stick with the LP and
build it up. "Almost all of those hands went up," Kubby said. "This
party is not breaking apart. This is not 1983.""
Robert Stacy McCain
reports that Kubby told his supporters, ""Please, I don't want anyone trashing this ticket." So he's apparently an LP loyalist, uniting behind Barr and Root."
Steve Perkins
reports on the radicals: "Kubby and Nolan then gave speeches in lobby, and still more others
pledged not to go to the morning session tomorrow… thus ensuring that a
less-balanced LNC will be elected. Again, that doesn’t HAVE to go that
way either. Say what you want, this convention has been no “purge”…
things played out in such a lopsided manner largely due to
all-or-nothing thinking, and poor floor management once emotions got
too strong."
Jason Pye
reports, "It was good to see David Nolan and Steve Kubby show up for the
reception and show their support for the ticket. There was no purging,
but there was healthy debate between two sincere factions that have
only the best interest of the party at heart."
Robert Stacy McCain
"complains" about his journalist duties: "The agenda for this evening? The Barr campaign staffers say tonight they're planning to put the
party back in Libertarian Party. And I have to cover that story. Work, work, work."
Miscellaneous:Steve Perkins
on Starchild: "Before I came out here, my preconception of Starchild for example was
based on the portrayal he often gets online… I thought he was some guy
who just shows up in costumes and tries to disrupt things because he
doesn’t take matters seriously. You know what? That image is
completely full of shit. In the Bylaws and Platform debates, he was
extremely knowledgeable about every plank being discussed, articulated
his positions eloquently and respectfully, and was nothing if not 100%
serious (attire aside)."
There was a guy in a Guy Fawkes mask (ala V for Vendetta) who kept jumping around on camera waving a Mary Ruwart sign during the C-SPAN coverage of the debate and nomination. I was wondering who it was --
this comment on the Agitator claims it was her press secretary. What a retard. His antics did nothing to help her campaign or the party.
David Weigel has an
amusing round-up about the bottom-tier candidates who didn't make it into the debate.
Future Posts:I am planning a final roundup of convention gossip, and well as a roundup of media and blogosphere reactions to the Barr/Root ticket. Unfortunately, I will be busy with a blackjack tournament for the next three days, so I probably won't get those posts up until later this week. The upside is, everyone at the convention should be back home by then and thus will have had a chance to post their reports and thoughts, so delaying a few days should allow for a more complete picture.
I'll also be blogging about the campaign, although probably not every day. Please bookmark or link my politics filter if you're interested in that coverage:
http://www.jacquelinepassey.com/politics/index.html